Shortstop Deli Menu

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Shortstop Deli is a top-notch deli specializing in mouth-watering sandwiches, salads, and wraps. Located in Ithaca, NY, this deli offers a variety of options for all tastes, including vegan choices. With options like the Double Sub, Grand Slam Sub, and Build Your Own Salad, there's something for everyone at Shortstop Deli. Don't miss out on their Hot Truck Subs, like the Grand Slam CSC Hot Truck and Grand Slam MBC Hot Truck, which are sure to satisfy your cravings. The casual atmosphere, friendly staff, and convenient amenities make Shortstop Deli a great spot for lunch or a late-night bite. Plus, with options for delivery, takeout, and catering, enjoying their delicious offerings is easy and convenient. Don't forget to stop by and try out their menu for a delightful dining experience.

Subs Salads and Wraps Hot Truck Subs Breakfast Chips XXL Cookies Fountain Beverages House Beverages Drinks Wings Soup and Hot Bar Pastries Ice Cream

Subs

Double Sub

Our double sub is a full meal, load up on toppings and don't forget a side and drink!
$13.09

Grand Slam Sub

The legendary shortstop giant sub if your appetite is BIG. Don't forget to grab a side and a drink!
$16.69

Single Sub

Our single size sub is perfect for a quick meal. Don't forget to grab a side and drink!
$9.49

Build Your Own Salad
$11.15

Build Your Own Wrap
$9.49

Salads and Wraps

Hot Truck Subs

Grand Slam CSC Hot Truck

Our "Poor Mans Pizza" with chicken breast
$16.79

Grand Slam MBC Hot Truck

The "Poor Mans Pizza" with crushed meatballs and red sauce.
$15.59

Grand Slam PMP Hot Truck

The "Poor Mans Pizza" on french bread with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese
$14.39

Grand Slam Sep-Pep Hot Truck

The WGC With Pepperoni and mushrooms
$15.59

Grand Slam SUI Hot Truck

Ground sausage, pepperoni and mushrooms on garlic bread with red sauce and mozzarella.
$16.79

Grand Slam The Big Willie Hot Truck

The PMP with Swiss cheese added, GrilledChicken, Bacon, Onions, Lettuce & Truck Sauce (created by Willie D, CU)
$18.59

Grand Slam The Little Sicilian Hot Truck

The PMP loaded with Meatballs, Ground-Sausage, Onions, Hot Sauce and Hot-n-Heavy (Garlic & Crushed Red peps)
$18.59

Grand Slam WGC Hot Truck

The "Poor Mans Pizza" made on homemade garlic bread
$14.39

Regular CSC Hot Truck

Our "Poor Mans Pizza" with chicken breast
$13.19

Regular MBC Hot Truck

The "Poor Mans Pizza" with crushed meatballs and red sauce.
$11.99

Regular PMP Hot Truck

The "Poor Mans Pizza" on french bread with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese
$10.79

Regular Sep-Pep Hot Truck

The WGC with pepperoni and mushrooms
$11.99

Regular SUI Hot Truck

Ground sausage, pepperoni and mushrooms on garlic bread with red sauce and mozzarella.
$13.19

Regular The Big Willie Hot Truck

The PMP with Swiss cheese added, GrilledChicken, Bacon, Onions, Lettuce & Truck Sauce (created by Willie D, CU)
$14.99

Regular The Little Sicilian Hot Truck

The PMP loaded with Meatballs, Ground-Sausage, Onions, Hot Sauce and Hot-n-Heavy (Garlic & Crushed Red peps)
$14.99

Regular WGC Hot Truck

The "Poor Mans Pizza" made on homemade garlic bread
$10.79

Bagel & Cream Cheese
$3.85

Bagel and Spread
$3.85

Egg and Cheese Sandwich

Choose your bagel or bread and we'll toast it with scrambled egg and cheese
$6.00

Egg and Meat Sandwich

Choose your bagel or bread and we'll toast it with scrambled egg and meat
$6.00

Egg Sandwich

Choose your bagel or bread and we'll toast it with scrambled egg
$5.40

Egg, Meat and Cheese Sandwich

Choose your bagel or bread and we'll toast it with scrambled egg, meat and cheese
$7.15

Hash Browns
$3.90

Pizza Bagel

Pizza for breakfast! Choose a bagel and we'll toast it with pizza sauce and mozzarella
$8.70

Plain Bagel
$2.05

Breakfast

Chips

Baked Lays
$2.89

Cape Cod Kettle Chips
$2.29

Cape Cod Reduced Fat Chips
$2.29

Cape Cod Salt and Vinegar Chips
$2.29

Cheetos Crunchy
$2.89

Cheetos Crunchy (2.75oz)
$3.79

Cheetos Flamin Hot
$2.89

Cheetos Puffs
$2.89

Classic Lays
$2.89

Dirty Cracked Pepper Big Bag
$5.55

Dirty Cracked Pepper Chips
$2.89

Dirty Funky Fusion Chips
$2.89

Dirty Jalapeno Big Bag
$5.55

Dirty Jalapeno Chips
$2.89

Dirty Maui Onion
$2.89

Dirty Mequite BBQ Chips
$2.89

Dirty Mesquite BBQ Big Bag
$5.55

Dirty Salt and Vinegar Big Bag
$5.55

Dirty Sea Salted Chips
$2.89

Dirty Sour Cream and Onion Big Bag
$5.55

Dirty Sour Cream and Onion Chips
$2.89

Dirty Sriracha Honey Chips
$2.89

Doritos Cool Ranch
$2.89

Doritos Cool Ranch (2.5oz)
$3.79

Doritos Nacho Cheese
$2.89

Doritos Nacho Cheese (2.5oz)
$3.79

Fritos Corn Chips
$2.89

Lays BBQ (2.25)
$3.79

Lays BBQ Chips
$2.89

Lays Classic (2.25)
$3.79

Pirate's Booty White Cheddar Puffs
$2.89

Pringles Cheddar Big Can
$5.75

Pringles Cheddar Cheese

Grab n' Go
$3.90

Pringles Original Big Can
$5.75

Pringles Orignal

Grab n' Go
$3.90

Pringles Sour Cream and Onion

Grab n' Go
$3.90

Pringles Sour Cream and Onion Big Can
$5.75

Quest Chili Lime Chips
$4.55

Ruffles Cheddar and Sour Cream (2.16oz)
$3.79

Ruffles Cheddar Sour Cream
$2.89

Ruffles Chips
$2.89

Salt and Vinegar Lays
$2.89

Smartfood White Cheddar (1.75oz)
$3.79

Smartfood White Cheddar Popcorn
$2.89

Sour Cream and Onion Lays
$2.89

Sun Chips Cheddar
$2.89

Sun Chips Garden Salsa
$2.89

Takis Buckin Ranch(1)
$3.85

Takis Fuego
$3.85

Takis Spicy Sweet
$3.85

Tostitos White Corn Chips
$3.35

Chocolate Chip Brownie
$3.59

Chocolate Chip XXL Cookie
$3.49

House Cinnamon Roll
$4.55

Oatmeal Rasin XXL Cookie
$3.49

Peanut Butter XXL Cookie
$3.49

White Chocolate Macadamia XXL Cookie
$3.49

XXL Cookies

Fountain Beverages

Add On Fountain Drink
$0.15

Fountain Drink
$2.15

Large Fountain Drink
$3.25

Medium Fountain Drink
$2.75

Small Fountain Drink
$2.15

Cappuccino Large
$4.19

Cappuccino Medium
$3.95

Cappuccino Regular
$3.59

Hot Cocoa Large
$4.19

Hot Cocoa Medium
$3.95

Hot Cocoa Regular
$3.59

Iced Coffee French Vanilla (24oz)
$3.90

Iced Coffee Mocha (24oz)
$3.90

Large Coffee
$3.45

Medium Coffee
$3.19

Regular Coffee
$3.00

House Beverages

Drinks

Aquafina (20oz)
$3.25

Barqs Root Beer (20oz)
$3.85

Canada Dry Ginger Ale (20oz)
$3.85

Cherry Coke (20oz)
$3.85

Coca Cola (20oz)
$3.85

Crush Grape (20oz)
$3.85

Crush Orange (20oz)
$3.85

Diet Coke (20oz)
$3.85

Diet Mountain Dew (20oz)
$3.85

Diet Pepsi (20oz)
$3.85

Dole Lemonade (20oz)
$3.85

Dr. Pepper (20oz)
$3.85

Gatorade Cool Blue (20oz)
$4.19

Gatorade Fruit Punch (20oz)
$4.19

Gatorade Lemon Lime (20oz)
$4.19

Hawaiian Punch (20oz)
$3.85

Lifewater 20oz
$4.19

Monster Energy (16oz)
$4.79

Mountain Dew (20oz)
$3.85

Mug Root Beer (20oz)
$3.85

Pepsi (20oz)
$3.85

Pure Leaf Lemon Tea
$4.45

Pure Leaf Raspberry Tea
$4.45

Pure Leaf Unsweetened Tea
$4.45

Red Bull (12oz)
$5.89

Sprite (20oz)
$3.85

Starbucks Coffee (15oz)
$6.15

Starbucks Frappuccino Mocha (15oz)
$6.15

Starry (20oz)
$3.85

Tropicana Apple Juice (10oz)
$3.59

Boneless Wings
$8.99

Chicken Wings
$10.19

Wings

Soup and Hot Bar

Chicken Noodle Soup Large
$8.29

Chicken Noodle Soup Regular
$7.19

Meat Chili Large
$8.29

Meat Chili Regular
$7.19

Apple Danish
$3.59

Blueberry Glazed Donut Holes
$4.69

Brown Sugar Pop Tart
$2.70

Cherry Danish (1)
$3.59

Cherry Pop Tart
$2.70

Chocolate Chip Muffin
$4.19

Chocolate Cupcake
$3.59

Cinnamon Roll
$3.59

Donut Chocolate Mini
$3.59

Donut Crunch Mini
$3.59

Donut Powdered Sugar Mini
$3.59

Donut Sticks
$2.99

Honey Bun Iced
$3.59

Oreo Brownie
$4.19

Pastries

Ice Cream

Ice Cream Closeout
$3.90